Websites & web design
Website Subscription vs Builder vs Agency: 3-Year Cost 2026
Website as a service, website builder or agency build? A 3-year total cost comparison with verified prices, your own time, exit checklist and decision matrix.

Key takeaways
In short:
- There are three ways to get a business website: a DIY website builder (you build it), website as a service (an agency builds and runs it for a monthly fee) and an agency purchase (one-off project, hosting and maintenance arranged separately).
- Over 36 months, the builder in our worked example costs about €1,100 in cash, while subscription and purchase cost €3,400 to €5,700 depending on the provider. Add your own time at €45 an hour and the three models land between €4,700 and €8,000.
- At €100 an hour, the builder is no longer the cheapest option. What your time is worth matters more than the list price.
- The biggest hidden cost is the exit: buy-out fees, designs you cannot export, and usage rights that end with the contract.
- Rule of thumb: a builder for solo founders with time, a subscription for local SMEs without a web team, and a purchase (or a subscription with clear ownership terms) for growing companies whose website must deliver leads.
This guide helps you choose a model. It is not a price list. For cost categories and how to compare website quotes in general, see our guide to business website costs. Here we answer a different question: which operating model is most economical for your business over three years, and what do you keep at the end? We checked every provider price on the provider's own pricing page on 6 November 2026. The examples are from the German market and are quoted in euros; prices, VAT and promotions differ by country and can change at any time.
What is the difference between a builder, a subscription and a purchase?
A website builder is a software-as-a-service platform such as Wix, Jimdo, Squarespace or IONOS MyWebsite. The platform handles hosting, SSL and technical updates. You handle page structure, copy, images, SEO and legal pages. You pay a subscription, and the site only runs on that platform.
Website as a service (also called a website subscription, web design subscription or "renting a website") means an agency designs, hosts and maintains your site for a monthly fee, often plus a set-up fee. Minimum terms, the amount of edits included and, above all, who owns the site when the contract ends vary completely between providers.
Buying a website is the classic agency project. You pay once for concept, design and build and receive the site with the usage rights agreed in the contract. After that you arrange hosting, maintenance, security updates and changes yourself, either through a maintenance contract or in-house.
Legal classification differs across Europe. In Germany, the Federal Court of Justice treats a contract to build, host and look after a website for a fixed term as a contract for work, not a lease (BGH, judgment of 4 March 2010, III ZR 79/09). "Renting" is usually marketing language. What counts is what the contract says.
What do the three models cost today? (verified list prices)
The table shows examples taken directly from pricing pages. It is not a full market overview. Watch the "VAT" column: some providers show gross prices and others show net.
| Model | Provider and plan | Price stated by provider | VAT | Term, notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Builder | Jimdo Grow | €20/month on 12 months (€240/year), €29 paid monthly | incl. VAT | Domain free for the first term, then €26/year; discounts apply to the first term only |
| Builder | Wix Core | €29.75/month on an annual plan | incl. VAT | Free domain for 1 year, first purchase only |
| Builder | Squarespace Core | €18/month billed annually, €24/month billed monthly | excl. VAT | Domain free for 1 year on annual plans, then standard price |
| Builder | IONOS MyWebsite Now Plus | €1/month for 12 months, €18/month shown struck through | incl. VAT | Promotional price, "partly dependent on minimum contract terms" |
| Subscription | Contentoren Website Starter | €99/month, no set-up fee | incl. VAT | 3–5 custom-designed pages, hosting, SSL, maintenance, small monthly changes |
| Subscription | Rocket Space subscription Starter | €0 set-up, €80/month (36 months) or €120/month (24 months) | net | Content changes billed separately; take-over after the term for a buy-out from €500 |
| Subscription | deine-website-mieten.de Advanced | €199/month, up to 5 pages | incl. VAT | 12-month minimum term, after which the provider says the site becomes yours |
| Subscription | HomepageAbo Pro | €29.99/month + €399 (promotion), regular €59.99 + €799 | not stated on the page | Up to 5 subpages, 4 changes per year |
| Purchase | Rocket Space one-off Starter | €2,500 one-off, 12 months hosting included | net | Hosting from month 13: €20/month; maintenance, updates and backups separate |
Two points stand out. First, promotional prices are not permanent. IONOS advertises the Plus plan at €1 a month for 12 months with €18 struck through next to it. Jimdo says discounts and the free domain apply to the first term only. Second, some providers do not state VAT clearly. If your business can reclaim input VAT, compare net prices. Otherwise compare gross prices. Either way, be consistent.
The 3-year total cost of ownership (TCO) comparison
Total cost of ownership (TCO) means every cost over the period of use, not just the starting price. We use 36 months because the minimum terms of the subscriptions we checked go up to 36 months and because a design rarely stays unchanged for longer.
Assumptions (replace them with your own figures)
- Scenario: a service business with five pages and a contact form, no online shop. All amounts are gross at Germany's 19% VAT; net prices have been converted.
- Value of your own time: €45 an hour, the average labour cost per hour worked in Germany in 2025 according to Destatis. The EU average was €34.90, and Luxembourg had the highest figure at €56.80. For owners whose time is billable, the real figure is usually much higher.
- Own time (assumption): builder 25 hours to set up plus 1.5 hours of upkeep a month. Subscription 12 hours of input (briefing, content, approvals) plus 0.5 hours a month. Purchase 15 hours of input plus 1 hour a month for CMS edits and coordinating with the maintenance provider.
- Maintenance contract for the purchase (assumption): €60 a month. This is a placeholder, not a market average. Use your provider's quote.
- Builder price: Jimdo Grow on the 12-month plan (€240/year), assuming that price also applies on renewal. Jimdo notes that discounts only apply to the first term.
- Example providers: Jimdo Grow (builder), Contentoren Website Starter and Rocket Space subscription Starter (subscription), Rocket Space one-off Starter (purchase). The scopes are similar but not identical.
The calculation
| Cost item (36 months, gross) | Builder: Jimdo Grow | Subscription: Contentoren Starter | Subscription: Rocket Space Starter | Purchase: Rocket Space Starter + maintenance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Set-up / project | €0 | €0 | €0 | €2,975 |
| Platform or monthly fee | €720 (3 × €240) | €3,564 (36 × €99) | €3,427 (36 × €95.20) | – |
| Hosting and SSL | included | included | included | €571 (months 13–36 at €23.80) |
| Domain | €52 (years 2–3 at €26) | not itemised in the package, ask | handled by the provider | ask in the quote |
| Legal texts / apps | €360 (legal texts add-on, €10/month) | ask in the quote | ask in the quote | ask in the quote |
| Maintenance and updates | done by the platform | included | included | €2,160 (assumed €60/month) |
| Content changes | your time | small changes included | ordered separately | your time |
| Total payments | €1,132 | €3,564 | €3,427 | €5,706 |
| Own time | 79 h → €3,555 | 30 h → €1,350 | 30 h → €1,350 | 51 h → €2,295 |
| Total cost at €45/h | €4,687 | €4,914 | €4,777 | €8,001 |
| Total cost at €100/h | €9,032 | €6,564 | €6,427 | €10,806 |
| Exit after 36 months | Content partly exportable, design stays on the platform | ask in the quote | Buy-out from €595 gross incl. source code | Site is yours within the agreed rights |
Sources: prices from Jimdo, Contentoren and Rocket Space; hourly value from Destatis. Own time and the maintenance contract are our assumptions.
What the numbers show and what they don't
- The builder is cheapest in cash. Once you count your own time, most of that lead disappears. At €100 an hour it is gone.
- A subscription is not automatically more expensive than buying. Price a purchase honestly with hosting and maintenance and it lands in the same range. The real differences are how payments are spread (one large payment or an even monthly rate) and the exit.
- The same price does not mean the same service. The table compares costs, not design quality, copywriting, page speed or enquiries. A cheap subscription with no edits included can end up costing more if every text change is billed.
- From month 37 the picture changes. In our example you then pay about €32 a month for the builder (plan, domain, legal texts), €99 for Contentoren Starter and about €84 for the purchase (hosting plus assumed maintenance). Sooner or later, every model needs a redesign.
Which hidden costs do most buyers overlook?
- Renewal at full price. Introductory discounts, free domains and "€1 for the first year" offers expire. Always budget the regular price from the second term onwards.
- VAT. Squarespace quotes prices excluding VAT, while Jimdo and Wix include it. At 19% VAT, that adds up to several hundred euros over three years.
- Apps, add-ons and transaction fees. Builders often charge extra for legal texts, booking features, mailboxes or payments. Jimdo, for example, charges €8.50 a month for Google Workspace and transaction fees for JimdoPay (Jimdo pricing).
- Changes beyond the allowance. Some subscriptions include only a few changes a year (HomepageAbo: 2 to 6), while others bill content changes separately (Rocket Space).
- Buy-out and data export. Leaving after the contract can mean a buy-out fee (Rocket Space: €500, €1,000 or €2,000 net depending on the package) or a fee for a copy of your content (HomepageAbo terms).
- Compliance work. Since 28 June 2025, the European Accessibility Act (Directive (EU) 2019/882) has required accessible websites where consumers can conclude contracts (shops, bookings, subscriptions); microenterprises providing services are exempt. Since 19 June 2026, traders who conclude distance contracts with consumers online must offer an electronic withdrawal function (Directive (EU) 2023/2673; in Germany § 356a BGB). Check who builds and maintains this in your model. Jimdo, for instance, lists a withdrawal button as a feature in all plans (Jimdo pricing). With a purchased site, it is usually a paid job for your agency.
- Technical operations after a purchase. With a self-hosted CMS such as WordPress, plugin updates, compatibility tests and security incidents are running costs. More on that in WordPress drawbacks for business websites.
- Rebuilding when you switch. You cannot take a builder design to another provider. According to the Wix Help Center, you cannot even switch the template of an existing Wix site; you have to create a new site.
Who owns the website? Ownership and exit compared
This is where the models differ most, and where three years from now things get expensive or cheap.
- Builder: your content is yours, but the site itself only runs on the platform. Wix states that Wix sites must run on Wix servers, although you can buy and manage your domain elsewhere (Wix Help Center). Squarespace exports only certain content as an XML file for WordPress. Style settings, custom CSS, product blocks and video blocks do not export (Squarespace Help Center). Jimdo's pricing page says your domain remains yours and can be transferred at any time.
- Subscription: everything depends on the contract. Among the providers we checked, terms range from full ownership after 12 months "including all content, designs and access" (deine-website-mieten.de), to a take-over for a buy-out fee including source code and database (Rocket Space), to a simple, non-transferable right of use for the contract term only, with design and technical set-up remaining the provider's property and the site taken offline at the end (HomepageAbo terms).
- Purchase: you get the usage rights the contract grants. German copyright law, for example, distinguishes between non-exclusive and exclusive rights, and anything not expressly agreed is determined by the purpose of the contract (§ 31 UrhG). Other EU countries have similar rules. "Bought" does not automatically mean you may freely reuse the source code, design files and image licences.
Exit checklist: settle these before you sign
- Domain: Is the domain registered to your company as the holder, not to the provider? Will you get the transfer (auth) code free of charge?
- Content: Will you receive copy, images, documents and form data in an open format (such as HTML, Markdown, CSV or XML)?
- Design and code: What usage rights do you have during and after the term? Exclusive or non-exclusive, time-limited or perpetual?
- Image licences: Do stock photo licences remain valid after you change provider?
- Accounts and data: Are Google Search Console, analytics, Google Business Profile, email and your newsletter tool registered in your name?
- Handover: Is there a buy-out fee? What does the handover cost, and what does it include (files, database, documentation, migration help)?
- Redirects: Will the provider help with 301 redirects so you keep your rankings after a move?
Terms and cancellation: what businesses need to know
The offers we checked range from cancel-anytime (Squarespace) to a 12-month minimum (deine-website-mieten.de) to 24 or 36 months. Rocket Space requires three months' notice before the end of the term; otherwise the subscription renews for another 12 months (Rocket Space). HomepageAbo's FAQ and terms contradict each other: 12 months according to the FAQ, one month according to the terms dated July 2025. Whenever you see contradictions like this, get the rule into the written quote.
Three legal points that are often missed (not legal advice):
- Consumer protection usually does not cover you. The EU Unfair Contract Terms Directive 93/13/EEC protects consumers, defined as natural persons acting outside their trade or business. In Germany, for example, standard terms that bind consumers for more than two years are invalid (§ 309 No. 9 BGB), but that rule does not apply directly to businesses (§ 310(1) BGB). A 36-month B2B commitment is generally possible.
- Germany: cancellable, but not for free. The Federal Court of Justice ruled that a customer may terminate such a website contract with a 36-month minimum term at any time (BGH, judgment of 27 January 2011, VII ZR 133/10). However, the provider generally keeps its claim to the agreed fee minus saved expenses, and the law presumes it is owed 5% of the fee for the work not yet performed (§ 648 BGB). Leaving early is therefore usually expensive. Rules in other countries differ, so check your local law.
- What you sign is what counts. Marketing claims on a website do not replace a contract clause. Where statements conflict, the contract prevails.
Which model fits which business?
| Criterion | Solo founder / freelancer | Local SME (trades, practice, law firm) | Growing mid-sized company focused on leads |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical need | Digital business card, a few pages, contact | 5–15 pages, local visibility, enquiries, occasional changes | Many service pages, landing pages, CRM or booking integration, tracking |
| Time for the website | Available but limited | Hardly any, no web team | Marketing team exists, but not for technical work |
| Recommendation | Builder, if you enjoy doing it yourself | Subscription, with a change allowance and clear exit terms | Purchase or subscription with ownership transfer and agreed extensions |
| What to watch | Renewal price, legal pages, export limits | Term, scope of changes, domain in your name | Usage rights, integrations, page speed, measurement, provider independence |
| Warning sign | You spend weekends in the editor | Every text change is billed extra | The site depends on a platform that cannot handle your integrations |
A hybrid path often makes sense: start on a builder, keep your domain with an independent registrar, and move to a professional solution after a year or two once the website has to generate revenue. If you are already on Wix or Jimdo, see our comparisons Wix alternative and Jimdo alternative. For a detailed subscription comparison, see HomepageAbo alternative.
Decide in five steps
- Set the goal: Should the site just inform, or bring in measurable enquiries? Without a lead goal, a builder is often enough.
- Value your own time honestly: Estimate your hours for set-up and upkeep and multiply them by your hourly value.
- Price three offers over 36 months: one-off + 36 × monthly + 3 × annual + extras, using renewal prices and consistently gross or net.
- Check the exit: Work through the checklist above. A cheap offer without exit terms is a risk.
- Play through "year 4": What will you pay each month after that, and what will you have to rebuild if you switch?
Questions to ask every provider
- What is the price from the second term onwards, and is it gross or net?
- How long is the minimum term and the notice period? Does the contract renew automatically, and for how long?
- How many changes per month or year are included? What does an extra hour cost?
- Who writes the copy, who supplies images, and who holds the image licences?
- Who implements new obligations such as accessibility, the withdrawal function or cookie consent, and does that cost extra?
- Who is the registered holder of the domain? Which accounts are in your name?
- What exactly do you receive when you cancel, in which format and at what price?
- Where is the site hosted, and is there a data processing agreement under the GDPR?
- How fast does support respond, and who is your contact person?
Conclusion
There is no single cheapest route. A builder costs the least in cash and is a good choice for solo founders with time to spare. Subscriptions and purchases are closer over three years than either side's marketing suggests. The deciding factors are the change allowance, the exit terms and the value of your own time. Price every offer over 36 months, include your own hours and get ownership, domain and data export confirmed in writing.
Contentoren's website packages are one version of the subscription model: a monthly rate with no set-up fee for hosting, maintenance and changes. The package prices are on our pricing page; the exact terms, including the minimum term and notice period, are set out in the written quote. Ask us about the exit terms too. You can see what the packages include on our website development page. If you would like to work through your three offers together, book a no-obligation call.
Sources
Accessed 6 November 2026
- Jimdo, pricing and plans (incl. FAQ on terms, renewal, domain, VAT): jimdo.com/de/preise
- Wix, premium plans: de.wix.com/pricing
- Wix Help Center, "Exporting your Wix site or embedding it elsewhere" (German): support.wix.com
- Wix Help Center, "Switching Your Site Template": support.wix.com
- Squarespace, pricing (incl. FAQ on VAT and terms): de.squarespace.com/preise
- Squarespace Help Center, "Export your site content" (updated 9 October 2026): support.squarespace.com
- IONOS, MyWebsite website builder: ionos.de/websites/homepage-baukasten
- Rocket Space, web design subscription (incl. FAQ on term, notice, buy-out): rocket-space.de/webdesign-abo-webseite-mieten-statt-kaufen and one-off prices: rocket-space.de
- deine-website-mieten.de (max2-consulting GmbH), packages and FAQ: deine-website-mieten.de
- HomepageAbo, pricing: homepageabo.de/preise; FAQ: homepageabo.de/faq; terms (July 2025): homepageabo.de/agb
- Contentoren, pricing: /pricing
- Destatis (Federal Statistical Office of Germany), press release No. 148 of 29 April 2026 (labour costs 2025: €45.00 per hour in Germany, €34.90 EU average): destatis.de
- German Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 4 March 2010, III ZR 79/09 (website system contract as a contract for work), PDF: czarnetzki.eu
- German Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 27 January 2011, VII ZR 133/10 (termination at any time, headnotes): lorenz.userweb.mwn.de
- EU law: Directive (EU) 2019/882 (European Accessibility Act), Directive (EU) 2023/2673 (withdrawal function, applies from 19 June 2026), Directive 93/13/EEC (unfair terms in consumer contracts)
- German law: § 309 BGB, § 310 BGB, § 356a BGB, § 648 BGB, § 31 UrhG
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to rent a website or to buy one?
It depends on the provider and on your own time. In our worked example, subscription and one-off purchase both land between roughly €4,800 and €8,000 over 36 months once maintenance and your own hours are included. Always compare the full three-year cost and check what you own when the contract ends.
What happens to a subscription website when the contract ends?
Only the contract decides. Some providers transfer the site to you after the minimum term, others hand it over for a buy-out fee, and some take it offline. Get usage rights, data export and domain transfer confirmed in writing before you sign.
Can I move a Wix or Squarespace site to another host?
Only partly. Wix states that Wix sites must run on Wix servers, although you can manage your domain elsewhere. Squarespace exports only certain content as an XML file for WordPress; style settings and custom CSS do not export. Switching usually means rebuilding the design.
How long do website subscriptions lock me in?
It varies widely. Among the providers we checked, terms range from cancel-anytime to 12-month minimums to 24 or 36 months with automatic renewal. Businesses get less protection than consumers, because EU unfair-terms rules such as Directive 93/13/EEC only cover consumer contracts.
Who should use a website builder?
Builders suit freelancers and micro-businesses who are happy to maintain a simple site themselves and have time to do it. Once the site has to generate leads, needs integrations or your hour is expensive, a subscription or agency build often catches up with the builder's price advantage.


